Guides / Formatting and design tools

Vellum vs. Kindle Create: Paid Polish or Amazon's Free Tool?

These two formatters could hardly be further apart. Vellum is a paid Mac app, $199.99 for ebooks or $249.99 including paperbacks, with a reputation for handsome interiors and files any store accepts. Kindle Create is Amazon's free app for Windows and Mac, made for Kindle ebooks and KDP paperbacks, and it saves Amazon's KPF format or EPUB. Mac owners who sell widely usually get their money's worth from Vellum; Amazon-only authors who want to spend nothing are well served by Kindle Create.

Updated October 1, 20266 min read
On this page
  1. Quick comparison
  2. About Vellum
  3. About Kindle Create
  4. Looks
  5. Selling outside Amazon
  6. Paperbacks
  7. Which computer you use
  8. Is the cost justified?
  9. How a session goes
  10. Keeping a series consistent
  11. Making the call
  12. Testing before upload
  13. Selling the book on BooksOasis
  14. In short
  15. Questions

Here we weigh up cost, computers, design, output, print layout and reach, based on what each company says about its own product, and suggest who should pick which.

VellumMac, one payment, refined.
Kindle CreateNo charge, made for Amazon.
OutputPortable files vs. KPF.
On WindowsOnly Kindle Create.

Quick comparison

VellumKindle Create
What you pay$199.99 (Ebooks) or $249.99 (Press), onceNothing
ComputerMac onlyWindows or Mac
FilesFor every major store, plus a print PDF with PressKPF for Amazon, EPUB, and KDP paperback layout
LookRefined built-in book stylesPlainer themes
Kinds of bookReflowable ebooks and printReflowable, print replica and comics
Testing firstFree to download; pay to generate filesFree throughout

About Vellum

Vellum formats manuscripts that are already written; it is not a drafting tool. Import a Word document and it splits the text into chapters and spots the scene breaks. Pick a book style and the chapter openings, drop caps and ornaments all change together, giving pages that resemble a traditionally published book with very little fiddling.

Vellum Ebooks ($199.99) lets you create as many ebooks as you like, and Vellum Press ($249.99) adds unlimited paperbacks. You are free to download it and see how your book looks, but you must buy a license before it will generate files for publishing. Those files suit all the main stores, so one book can go to Amazon, Apple Books, Kobo, Google Play and BooksOasis, and to any printer.

About Kindle Create

Amazon's free app, for Windows and Mac, prepares a completed manuscript as a Kindle ebook and a KDP paperback. It identifies the chapters, applies a theme and handles the paperback pages, working out margins and inserting page numbers on its own. Amazon states the result can be published at any KDP trim size.

Beyond standard reflowable books, it handles print replica titles with fixed layouts and comics using Guided View. KPF, the format KDP uses for Kindle ebooks and paperbacks, is its main output, and it can export EPUB as well.

Looks

Design is Vellum's calling card. Its styles are carefully crafted: chapter openings are well balanced, drop caps are attractive and scene breaks carry tasteful ornaments. Some authors buy it for the appearance alone. Kindle Create's themes are tidy and easy to read but more basic, with fewer settings. In genres where readers notice the interior, literary fiction, romance and fantasy among them, Vellum's finish can become part of the book's charm.

Selling outside Amazon

Everything about Kindle Create points at KDP, and a KPF file is only useful on Amazon. Selling elsewhere means exporting an EPUB and testing it thoroughly, plus finding a print-ready PDF for any printer that is not KDP. Vellum is neutral, and its files are welcome everywhere. If you sell wide now, or might later, this matters more than the price tag.

Paperbacks

Each can produce a print edition. Kindle Create lays out KDP paperbacks, setting margins and page numbers for you. Vellum Press outputs print-ready PDFs in standard trim sizes for any printer, using the same refined styles as the ebook. Whichever you choose, leave the cover until last and build it from the printer's template, since the spine width follows the finished page count.

Which computer you use

Vellum is Mac-only; Kindle Create runs on Windows and Mac. A Windows or Chromebook user cannot run Vellum without getting a Mac. Kindle Create remains open to them, as do cross-platform tools such as LiberScript, which works in a browser, and Atticus, which covers Windows, Mac, Linux and Chromebook.

Is the cost justified?

Kindle Create is free. Vellum Press is $249.99 one time and covers unlimited books. With a single Amazon title, free is very hard to beat. With a run of books sold in many stores, Vellum's price spread across them is small, and its finish and portability can pay for themselves through a more professional book and broader sales.

How a session goes

StepKindle CreateVellum
1Install, then open the Word fileImport the Word file
2Check the chapter breaksCheck the chapter breaks
3Pick a theme and add a title page and other elementsPick a book style and add front and back matter
4Preview on simulated Kindle screens and paperback pagesSet the trim size and preview on simulated screens and pages
5Save a KPF and upload it to KDPGenerate ebook and print files for each store

Keeping a series consistent

A series reads better when every volume matches. In Vellum, reuse the same book style, trim size and elements and the books line up automatically. In Kindle Create, apply the same theme and settings to each new title.

Later corrections, whether a typo or new back matter, mean exporting again and re-uploading. Vellum's one set of files covers all stores together. With Kindle Create, the KPF on Amazon and any EPUB or PDF used elsewhere each need updating separately. In both cases, file the final versions with the manuscript.

Making the call

Choose Vellum if you work on a Mac and publish several books, sell beyond Amazon or plan to, and want a refined interior without much effort.

Choose Kindle Create if you sell only on Amazon and want a free tool, you use Windows, or you are making a print replica book or a comic for Kindle.

If neither suits you

LiberScript works in any browser and brings together writing, a whole-manuscript critique and a design studio, exporting print-ready PDF, EPUB and DOCX with passes from $19.99 a month. Atticus is a one-time $147 and runs on Windows, Mac, Linux and Chromebook. Reedsy Studio is free, offering three templates and four trim sizes. Our guide to the best book formatting tools compares them all.

Three writers, three tools

A thriller writer on Windows who sells only through Amazon formats in Kindle Create at no cost and uploads the KPF to KDP.

A romance writer on a Mac publishing every two months in several stores buys Vellum Press for its refined, portable files.

A non-fiction writer on a Chromebook selling widely uses LiberScript, because Vellum will not run there and Kindle Create's files are aimed at Amazon.

Testing before upload

Read the ebook on both a phone and a tablet, following every table-of-contents link. Look at the print PDF at 100%, with an eye on the inner margin of long books (see book print margins), and order a proof copy when you can.

Selling the book on BooksOasis

BooksOasis needs an EPUB for the ebook, and for every print edition an interior PDF and a full-wrap cover PDF. Vellum's output uploads as it is. From Kindle Create, export the ebook as EPUB, and supply a print-ready PDF for print. Once the interior is in, BooksOasis states the printing cost, gives the exact cover dimensions and spine width with a template, and runs an automated print-readiness check before review.

Where BooksOasis fits

  • Works with standard EPUB and print-ready PDF files from any formatter.
  • Tests print files automatically and supplies a precise cover template.
  • Every ebook sale pays you its price minus a small distribution fee; plans begin at $29.99 a year.

What it doesn't do: BooksOasis cannot use KPF files, and it does not format manuscripts or create covers.

See plans and pricing

In short

Vellum offers Mac users beautifully styled, store-neutral books for one payment. Kindle Create offers anyone a free route to Kindle ebooks and KDP paperbacks. Go with Vellum on a Mac when you sell widely, with Kindle Create when Amazon is your only store and the budget is zero, and with a cross-platform tool when neither runs on your computer.

Questions

Should I pay for Vellum when Kindle Create is free?

Mac users who publish several titles across more than one store often decide Vellum's refined styles and portable files are worth the money. A single plain book sold only on Amazon may need nothing beyond Kindle Create.

What is Vellum's price?

A one-time $199.99 for Vellum Ebooks, or $249.99 for Vellum Press, which adds paperbacks. It is a macOS app.

Is Kindle Create really free?

Yes. Amazon offers it at no cost for Windows and Mac.

Which file types come out of Kindle Create?

EPUB, and Kindle Package Format (KPF), the format Amazon prefers for Kindle ebooks and paperbacks.

Are Vellum's files usable beyond Amazon?

Yes. It generates files for the main stores, and with Vellum Press, print-ready PDFs that any printer can use.

Which produces nicer interiors?

Vellum has a strong reputation for elegant, traditional-looking pages. Kindle Create's themes are plainer.

Can Kindle Create lay out a paperback?

Yes. It sets margins automatically, numbers the pages, and works with every KDP trim size.

Is there a Vellum trial?

You can download Vellum and test it with your manuscript at no cost, but generating files to publish requires a purchase.

I use Windows. What then?

Vellum is Mac-only. On Windows, try Kindle Create or a cross-platform tool such as LiberScript or Atticus.

Do these files work on BooksOasis?

BooksOasis needs an EPUB and print-ready PDFs. Vellum's output works as it is; with Kindle Create, export an EPUB for the ebook and supply a print-ready PDF for print.

Reach readers off Amazon

Put your Vellum or Kindle Create EPUB and a print PDF on BooksOasis, and each ebook sale pays you the entire price.
See plans and pricing