Below we work through cost, devices, writing, design, files, print and reach, drawing on what each company publishes about its product.
Side by side
| Atticus | Kindle Create | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | $147, one time, with updates | Nothing |
| Devices | Windows, Mac, Linux, Chromebook and browser, also offline | Windows or Mac |
| Drafting | Built in | Not offered; needs a finished file |
| Themes | Adjustable in detail | Fewer, simpler choices |
| Files produced | Ebook plus print-ready PDF suited to any store | Amazon's KPF or an EPUB, plus KDP paperback layout |
| Refund | 30 days | Not applicable |
What each tool is
Atticus is an app for writing and formatting books. You pay $147 once, all later updates come with it, and you have 30 days to ask for your money back. It works on Windows, Mac, Linux and Chromebook, and in the browser on desktops and tablets. Because it is a progressive web app, it keeps working without a connection.
You can write the book inside Atticus or bring a manuscript in. Its themes let you change heading styles, fonts, spacing, scene-break ornaments and other details while watching a live preview. The exports are ebooks and print-ready PDFs that any store or printer will take.
Kindle Create is Amazon's free download for Windows and Mac. Give it a completed manuscript and it turns it into a Kindle edition and a KDP paperback. It finds the chapters, applies a theme and lays out the paperback with margins and page numbers set for you. Amazon says every KDP trim size is supported.
It copes with reflowable books, print replica titles and comics with Guided View. Files are saved as Kindle Package Format (KPF), the format KDP favors, or as EPUB.
Where they differ
Money
Kindle Create costs nothing at all. Atticus is $147 a single time and covers as many books as you like. If you have one book bound for Amazon only, the free option is hard to beat. Across several books the per-book cost of Atticus shrinks fast, and its extras start to count for more than the price.
Drafting the book
Atticus combines a writing space with its formatter, which suits authors who want everything in one place. Kindle Create begins where writing ends, so the drafting happens first in Word, Google Docs, Scrivener or another editor. Authors attached to their current writing app will not mind; those without one avoid a switch by choosing Atticus.
The look of the interior
With Atticus you can fine-tune a theme until a book, or a whole series, has a recognizable style. Kindle Create's themes read cleanly but give you fewer dials. In genres where buyers notice the interior, the extra control is worth having.
Selling on other stores
KPF files exist for Amazon, and Kindle Create is organized around KDP. It can save an EPUB for other retailers, but test that file properly, and you will still need a separate print-ready PDF for any printer other than KDP.
Atticus output is not tied to a store. One ebook file and one print PDF can be uploaded to Amazon, Apple Books, Kobo, Google Play, IngramSpark and BooksOasis alike. For authors who publish wide, or expect to, that is a real advantage.
Print interiors
Each can prepare a paperback. Kindle Create handles KDP paperbacks with automatic margins and page numbers; Atticus exports print-ready PDFs at various trim sizes for any printer. Whatever you use, give long books enough inside margin (our guide to book print margins explains why) and design the cover at the very end from the printer's template, once the page count is fixed.
Devices and working offline
Kindle Create installs on Windows and Mac only. Atticus runs on almost anything, Linux and Chromebooks included, works offline and keeps your books available on each device you use. Anyone who writes on a Chromebook or swaps between computers will find Atticus easier.
What the work looks like
Kindle Create, step by step:
- Download and install the app.
- Open the Word file and confirm where the chapters start.
- Choose a theme, then insert a title page and anything else you need.
- Look over the preview, which imitates Kindle devices and printed pages.
- Save the KPF and upload it to KDP.
Atticus, step by step:
- Write in the app or import the manuscript.
- Review the chapter breaks.
- Choose a theme and adjust it.
- Add front and back matter and set the trim size.
- Preview both ebook and print, then export files for every store.
Five books later
Imagine releasing a book every year for five years. Kindle Create stays free throughout. Atticus works out at roughly $29 per book over that stretch, updates included.
If every one of those books is simple and sold only on Amazon, the free app may do the job. If you want wide sales, a signature design or one app for writing and layout, Atticus buys a lot of flexibility for little per title. Compared with editing and cover design, formatting software is a modest expense, so pick whichever tool improves the books and suits how you work.
Series and revisions
Atticus lets you reuse a customized theme so each volume in a series matches; Kindle Create lets you apply the same theme and settings again. When a book changes, Atticus's one set of files covers every store, whereas with Kindle Create you update the KPF on Amazon and, separately, any EPUB or PDF used elsewhere. In both cases, store the final files with the manuscript.
Choosing between them
Atticus makes more sense if you plan several books or a series, sell or intend to sell beyond Amazon, care about controlling the interior design, or want to write and format in one app on any device.
Kindle Create makes more sense if you have a single simple book for Amazon alone, want to pay nothing for formatting, or need a print replica edition or a Kindle comic.
Other tools worth a look
LiberScript is a browser workspace with a writing editor, a whole-manuscript critique and a design studio; it exports print-ready PDF, EPUB and DOCX, it is free to write in, with export plans from $19.99 a month. Vellum is a refined Mac-only app at $199.99 for ebooks or $249.99 including paperbacks. Reedsy Studio costs nothing and offers three templates and four trim sizes. Our round-up of the best book formatting tools weighs them up side by side.
Three writers, three picks
A debut novelist with a short book in Kindle Unlimited uses Kindle Create and spends nothing.
A fantasy writer working across a Windows PC and a Chromebook on a long series buys Atticus, builds one theme for the series and publishes everywhere.
A memoir writer who wants feedback before hiring an editor runs LiberScript's critique first and formats the book there too.
Before you upload
Open the ebook on a phone, then on a tablet, tapping through every table-of-contents link. View the print PDF at 100% size, and order a physical proof when you can.
Putting the book on BooksOasis
For each title, BooksOasis needs an EPUB for the ebook, then a PDF of the interior and a full-wrap cover PDF for every print edition. Files from Atticus upload as they are. If you used Kindle Create, export the ebook as EPUB and prepare a separate print-ready PDF for the paperback. After the interior upload, BooksOasis tells you what printing costs, how big the cover must be and how wide the spine is, with a template to match, and an automatic print-readiness check before the book goes to review.
Where BooksOasis fits
- Takes standard EPUB and print-ready PDF files, whichever tool made them.
- Checks print files automatically and supplies an exact cover template.
- Pays you the price of every ebook minus a small distribution fee; yearly plans start at $29.99.
What it doesn't do: BooksOasis can't take KPF files, and it doesn't format manuscripts or design covers.
See plans and pricingIn short
For a plain book sold only on Amazon, Kindle Create is a reasonable choice that costs nothing. Atticus asks for $147 once and returns a writing space, finer design control and store-neutral files on almost any device. Planning more than one book, or sales beyond Amazon? Then Atticus usually pays for itself.
Questions
How much is Atticus?
A single payment of $147. Future updates are included and there is a 30-day money-back guarantee.
Does Kindle Create cost anything?
No. Amazon gives it away for Windows and Mac.
Which computers can run them?
Kindle Create needs Windows or a Mac. Atticus also works on Linux and Chromebooks and in a web browser, with or without an internet connection.
Which is the better choice for selling on several stores?
Atticus. Its ebook and print PDF are neutral files any store accepts. Kindle Create can save an EPUB, but its main KPF output only goes to Amazon.
Can I draft the book inside either app?
Only in Atticus, which has a writing editor. Kindle Create expects the manuscript to be finished already.
Which offers more control over the look?
Atticus, because its themes can be adjusted in detail. Kindle Create keeps its options simple.
Can Kindle Create handle paperbacks?
Yes. Margins and page numbers are set for you, and any KDP trim size can be used.
Is Atticus good value?
For several books, wide distribution or a distinctive design, many authors find it is. One plain book for Amazon alone may not need it.
What else should I look at?
LiberScript (runs in the browser, includes a whole-manuscript critique and exports DOCX), Vellum (Mac only) and the free Reedsy Studio.
Can I upload these files to BooksOasis?
Yes, as long as you give it an EPUB and print-ready PDFs. Atticus output goes straight in; with Kindle Create, export EPUB and add a separate print-ready PDF for each paperback or hardcover.
Sell your book outside Amazon too
Bring the EPUB and print PDF from either tool to BooksOasis and receive the whole price of each ebook you sell.