A book that suits Reedsy Studio's layouts and sizes is very well served by a free tool. Authors who want more say over appearance, notes on the writing before layout, or a DOCX for an editor should look harder at LiberScript. Below, the two are set side by side using the features and prices each company lists.
The two compared
| LiberScript | Reedsy Studio | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | Passes: $19.99 a month, $79.99 a year, or $169.99 for life | None |
| Where it runs | Web browser | Web browser |
| Layout | Design studio, previewed live | Three templates: Classic, Romance and Reedsy |
| Paperback sizes | Set in the design studio | 6 x 9, 5.5 x 8.5, 5 x 8 or 4.25 x 6.87 inches |
| Writing feedback | whole-manuscript critique of the manuscript | None included |
| Export formats | Print-ready PDF, EPUB, DOCX | EPUB 3, print-ready PDF, plain PDF |
| Human help | Done-for-you editing, formatting and covers | A marketplace of freelancers |
Meet the tools
Reedsy Studio
Reedsy Studio used to be called the Reedsy Book Editor. It is made by Reedsy, the marketplace that matches authors with editors, designers and marketers, and it costs nothing to use for writing and layout.
Reedsy describes three outputs: a reflowable EPUB 3 for reading on any screen, a print-ready PDF prepared for print-on-demand (links stripped, images in CMYK), and an ordinary PDF for reading on a screen. The free templates, Classic, Romance and Reedsy, vary in typeface and page design, and paperbacks come in the four sizes shown in the table.
The appeal is its simplicity: few choices, a tidy result and no bill.
LiberScript
LiberScript carries a book all the way from first draft to finished files, inside the browser. You can type straight into its editor or import a manuscript, then use word targets, story beats and sticky notes to plan. A whole-manuscript critique works through the manuscript one chapter at a time.
In the design studio you change type, headings and page layout and watch the interior update as you go. Exports are a print-ready PDF at the trim size you pick, an EPUB and a DOCX. The passes are listed in the table above. The same company will also quote per project for ghostwriting, editing, formatting and cover design.
How they differ in practice
Cost
Reedsy Studio is free, and writing in LiberScript is free too with one project. Exporting costs $19.99 for a month, which easily covers a book's layout and proofing. For a plain book that suits one of Reedsy's templates, free is the obvious winner. The real test is whether LiberScript's extra design freedom, feedback and Word export are worth more to you than they cost.
Control over the look
Reedsy's three templates are well made, but the remaining options are few, so your interior may resemble other books built on the same template. LiberScript lets you set typefaces, heading designs, spacing and layout yourself with the preview running. That matters most in genres with strong visual conventions, or for a series that should share a distinctive style.
Page sizes
Most novels and a good share of non-fiction fit Reedsy's four sizes. Larger formats such as 7 x 10 or 8.5 x 11 inches, common for workbooks, cookbooks and illustrated titles, are not offered. Look at the sizes your printer supports and confirm your tool handles the one you want before you begin layout.
Notes on the writing
LiberScript's whole-manuscript critique reads the manuscript and points out problems with pacing, clarity and consistency, chapter by chapter. It does not replace a human editor, yet it can surface issues while fixing them is still cheap. With Reedsy, feedback means hiring a professional through its marketplace. Plenty of authors use both kinds of help at different points.
File types
You get an EPUB and a print-ready PDF from either. Reedsy adds a plain PDF for screen reading, handy for review copies. LiberScript adds a DOCX, the format editors, agents and co-writers usually ask for. Whatever the source, test the EPUB on a phone and view the PDF at 100% before you upload.
Getting human help
Each offers a way to bring in professionals. Through Reedsy's marketplace you pick and hire freelancers yourself, from editors to cover artists. LiberScript quotes per project for done-for-you work before you commit, so formatting, editing or the cover can be handed over without leaving the app you wrote in.
A typical session
Reedsy Studio: start a new book, paste or import the chapters, pick a template and a trim size, add front and back matter, then export. A clean manuscript can often be done in an afternoon.
LiberScript: import the manuscript (or carry on writing in the editor), run the critique and revise if you wish, then style the interior in the studio while watching the preview. Choose a trim size and export a PDF and an EPUB, plus a DOCX if you need one. The critique costs some time at the start but can save a round of corrections later.
Across several books
For one book, nothing beats free, and LiberScript is free too until you export; then one $19.99 monthly pass covers the files. Over a run of books, the one-time $169.99 lifetime pass means you never pay per book again. Either is small beside an editor's fee or a cover design; what matters is whether the extra control and feedback make the books better.
Editors and beta readers
Before publication, most manuscripts go out to other people. Editors tend to use Word with tracked changes, while beta readers often like a PDF or an ebook. Reedsy's plain PDF is a convenient way to send a readable copy. With LiberScript's DOCX export, the editing round trip is simple: send the file, get the marked-up version back, and fold the changes in before layout. Settle this early, because changing tools halfway through editing is where formatting errors creep in.
Which to pick
Go with Reedsy Studio if you want formatting to cost nothing, one of its three templates suits your book and your trim size is on its list, or you intend to hire people through Reedsy's marketplace anyway.
Go with LiberScript if you want more control over the design, would like a whole-manuscript critique before layout, need Word exports or bigger trim sizes, or might want to hand formatting or the cover to someone later without changing tools.
Three writers, three decisions
A debut novelist on a tight budget with a tidy manuscript uses Reedsy Studio's Classic template at 5.5 x 8.5 inches and uploads the result to BooksOasis and KDP.
A memoir writer who wants notes before paying an editor takes a month pass in LiberScript, runs the critique, rewrites two chapters, then exports a DOCX for a beta reader and the print and ebook files for the stores.
A series writer after a signature look designs book one in LiberScript's studio and reuses those settings for each new installment.
Final checks
Read the EPUB in two different apps and on a phone, tapping through every table-of-contents entry. Look at the print PDF at 100%, watching the inner margin on thicker books (our guide to book print margins explains why). Order a printed proof when possible and leave the cover until the page count is final.
From either tool to BooksOasis
Both editors produce what BooksOasis asks for: an EPUB for the ebook, plus an interior PDF and a full-wrap cover PDF for each print edition. When the interior is uploaded, BooksOasis counts the pages, quotes the printing cost and gives the exact cover size and spine width along with a template to download. Both files then go through an automatic print-readiness check before review.
Where BooksOasis fits
- Takes the EPUB and print PDFs from LiberScript, Reedsy Studio or any other editor.
- Checks print files automatically and provides an exact cover template.
- Pays you the price of each ebook minus a small distribution fee; plans start at $29.99 a year.
What it doesn't do: BooksOasis won't format your manuscript or design your cover.
See plans and pricingIn short
Reedsy Studio is truly free and makes a clean job of an ordinary book with one of three solid templates. LiberScript charges a modest amount and gives more design freedom, a whole-manuscript critique, Word export and optional done-for-you help. Begin with Reedsy Studio if your book fits it, and move to LiberScript when you need the tool to do more.
Questions
Does Reedsy Studio cost anything?
No. Reedsy states that everything you need to write and format a book in Reedsy Studio is free, and will stay that way.
How is LiberScript priced?
By time. A month is $19.99 and a year $79.99, and lifetime access is $169.99 once.
Are they both browser apps?
Yes. Each runs online, so Windows, Mac, Linux and Chromebook users can all work in them.
Which offers more layouts and sizes?
Reedsy Studio has three free templates and four paperback sizes, from 6 x 9 inches down to 4.25 x 6.87. LiberScript's design studio gives finer control over type and page layout.
Can either export a Word file?
LiberScript can, alongside print-ready PDF and EPUB. Reedsy Studio's exports are EPUB 3, a print-ready PDF and a standard PDF.
Will either give feedback on my writing?
LiberScript has an whole-manuscript critique built in. Reedsy Studio sticks to writing and formatting, and Reedsy's marketplace is where you would pay a human editor.
Can I pay someone to do the formatting?
LiberScript can take on the editing, the formatting or the cover for you, quoted per project. Reedsy's marketplace lets you hire freelancers yourself.
Which suits a first book?
If your book fits a Reedsy Studio template and trim size, it is an excellent free starting point. If you want more design say or feedback first, pick LiberScript.
Can I switch from one to the other?
Yes. Export the manuscript from one, import it into the other, then set the design again and check the headings and front matter.
Can I sell the files on BooksOasis?
Yes. BooksOasis takes EPUB and print-ready PDF files and runs an automatic check on print files.
Sell the book you just formatted
Whichever editor you used, bring its EPUB and print PDF to BooksOasis and receive the full price of each ebook sale.